Algorithmic grocery pricing could hike costs for those with dietary restrictions
Experts warn AI-driven surveillance pricing could exploit consumers with fewer alternatives, such as those with religious or health-based food needs.
Explainer
An expert told a parliamentary committee that algorithmic pricing could lead to higher grocery costs for people with religious or health-based dietary restrictions. Sarah-Louise Ruder, an adjunct professor at the University of the Fraser Valley, said this type of surveillance pricing has been seen in the United States. She made the comments to the House of Commons ethics committee, which is examining the use of artificial intelligence in setting prices. Liberal MP Fares Al Soud raised the issue by describing his own shopping habits as a Muslim consumer.
Al Soud explained that his purchasing patterns reveal he has fewer alternatives for certain products. "I'm Muslim, I'm Arab, there are certain things about my shopping habits that can be inferred. Pork is not on my grocery list. I'm not a very effective person to advertise alcohol to ... and this is also a reality for many other communities. Hindu Canadians, Jewish Canadians, those with celiac," he said. He asked if AI-driven systems risked charging these consumers more because of their limited choices. Ruder agreed, saying, "If something is essential to you, or if it is a frequent buy, that can change the inferred willingness to pay for a product in a way that could be a negative impact for different cultural practices and households."
READ MORE: Grocery stores could use personal data for surveillance pricing, expert warns
READ MORE: Record diesel prices squeeze farm margins, grocery impact still unclear
What is surveillance pricing and how does it work?
Surveillance pricing uses personal data to set individualized prices, distinct from traditional market-based pricing. Renjie Butalid of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute called for a clear line between the two approaches. He illustrated the risk with the example of a parent urgently needing baby formula who could be charged more by a system detecting their limited options. Butalid recommended "a general prohibition on surveillance pricing where businesses use personal information, behavioral data, or inferences about individual consumers to determine individualized prices." Emily Osborne of the Canadian Shield Institute for Public Policy said this practice creates a black box for customers who cannot see or understand the personalized prices they are shown.
Companies gather data from various sources to fuel these pricing algorithms. Osborne said firms use IP addresses, device types, postal codes and any information shared during transactions. She added that behavioural data, like mouse movements on a webpage, can indicate a shopper's desperation. Companies may also purchase consumer profiles from data brokers. This detailed data collection over decades has created extensive digital profiles, said Keldon Bester of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project. He warned that using these profiles for pricing decisions moves the concern into a new area affecting economic well-being.
How widespread is algorithmic pricing in Canada?
At least 60 companies in Canada offer algorithmic pricing services to clients, according to findings from the Competition Bureau cited by Bester. He referenced a U.S. study which found Instacart charged some customers 23 per cent more than others. A spokesperson for Instacart said those experiments ended a year ago and did not involve personalized pricing, adding the company has committed to not using surveillance pricing. Butalid noted it is often unclear to consumers when they are facing algorithmic prices. He predicted these strategies will become more widespread as artificial intelligence makes them cheaper and easier to apply.
Are Canadian grocers using this technology?
Canadian grocers have stated they will not use in-store electronic shelf labels for surveillance or personalized pricing, Ruder told the committee. She said implementing such a system in physical stores would currently be challenging, requiring additional data collection like video feeds. However, electronic labels do enable other algorithmic price changes, like raising the cost of coffee in the morning or popsicles on a hot day. Ruder said evidence of surveillance pricing exists for online and physical grocery stores in the U.S. Novello Desserts reported in October that experts warned grocery stores could use personal data for this purpose, though major chains said they had no plans to do so. The Liberal government has suggested its proposed privacy legislation could address surveillance pricing, though the term is not mentioned in the bill.
With files from The Canadian Press, Canadian Grocer and CP24
Renée Bouchard writes about food, restaurants and grocery prices across Canada for Novello Desserts.