Personal gestures from staff boost tips at Canadian restaurants, data shows

VANCOUVER · Personal gestures from restaurant staff, like a manager's visit or acknowledging a guest's preference, are strongly linked to higher tips, according to new data from a Canadian restaurant technology company. The analysis of over 600,000 tables across more than 50 upscale casual restaurants in Canada and the U.S. found that 20.6% of tables receiving a verified gesture left a tip of 20% or more, compared with 17.8% of tables without one. Average tips were higher at every location studied. The findings come as a separate report indicates 67% of tipped hospitality workers say their tips have declined over the past two years.

The study was conducted by Vancouver-based Guestologie, a guest recognition platform, from June 15 to September 6, 2026. The company's technology identifies guests in real time and recommends specific actions for staff, such as an intentional manager visit or recognizing a loyal guest. The platform records whether those actions occur, allowing for comparison between tables where recognition happened and those where it did not. To account for other factors, researchers also compared tables within the same restaurant, during the same month and with the same party size, finding an even more pronounced difference of 20.7% versus 16.5%. "This was an observational analysis, so we're careful not to claim that recognition alone caused the difference," said Ryan Volberg, founder and CEO of Guestologie. "But because it draws on real restaurant transactions, it offers a clear view of how closely personalized hospitality and more generous tipping are connected." Volberg, who has spent two decades building restaurant technology, said the payment terminal has become a symbol of tipping fatigue, but the core issue is often what guests are getting in return for their money.

He argued that the problem isn't always what guests are being asked to pay. "Think about the difference between paying for a dinner where you were treated like just another transaction and one where the staff remembered you, made you feel welcome and genuinely cared about your experience," Volberg said. "The same 20% tip feels very different in those two situations. One is given joyfully while the other creates resentment due to the sense of obligation."

READ MORE: Ontario restaurant accessibility test finds widespread barriers for people with disabilities

READ MORE: 16 Montreal-area restaurants and grocers fined for hygiene violations in September

The data aligns with sentiments expressed by servers in a recent report from Actual, which found 62% of tipped workers believe gratuities should reflect service quality rather than simply the size of the bill. Volberg said this is an important message for restaurant operators. "We shouldn't be asking how to get guests to tip more. We should be asking how to deliver hospitality that makes them want to," he said.

Volberg outlined specific, low-cost actions restaurants can take to make customers feel recognized. He emphasized the power of an intentional manager visit, which can take less than two minutes. "There's an enormous difference between a manager stopping by to ask, 'How's everything tonight?' and one who approaches a guest and says, 'I wanted to personally thank you for being such a loyal customer. We really appreciate you choosing to spend your evenings with us,'" he explained. "The first is routine service. The second is genuine recognition."

Other actions include welcoming returning guests by name, remembering their favourite table or drink, and recognizing when a regular hasn't visited for a while. Volberg said these practices do not require expensive giveaways, complicated loyalty programs or significantly more work from staff. "What it requires is knowing something about the guest," he said. He noted that restaurants already collect vast information through reservation and point-of-sale systems, but this data rarely reaches servers when it matters.

For independent restaurants, Volberg suggested starting with simple guest notes and focused pre-shift discussions. Guestologie's platform uses machine learning to understand each guest's relationship with the brand, recommend actions to strengthen it and learn from the results. "The goal isn't to replace genuine hospitality with technology," Volberg said. "It's to make great hospitality easier to deliver, consistently, to more guests." The company's analysis indicates that recognition is something restaurants can deliberately and systematically improve.

With files from Retail Insider