Aviation expert says Canada's air traffic system a model for U.S. after outage
John Gradek of McGill University says Canada's NAV Canada is more strong and modernized than the U.S. system.
OTTAWA · An aviation management expert says Canada is far less likely than the United States to experience a nationwide flight grounding like the one that halted U.S. air travel last Friday. John Gradek, a faculty lecturer in supply networks and aviation management at McGill University, says the Canadian system is more strong and modernized and should serve as a model for its southern neighbour. He argued that the funding model of the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration is the core problem, as it relies on political decisions for infrastructure investment. The FAA issued a nationwide ground stop order on Friday afternoon, citing communications issues affecting nearly two dozen air traffic control centres that direct planes between airports. The order, which lasted more than four hours, was the country's longest ground stop in 25 years and the second nationwide halt of all departures since the September 11, 2001, attacks. Airports across Canada suspended flights to and from the United States, and Air Canada cancelled its remaining U.S. flights for the day. The U.S. order was lifted late Friday, but airlines warned it could take days for operations to return to normal.
Gradek said the U.S. should look to Canada for its model. "They should look north, they should look to Canada," he said. He explained that the American system's fragility stems from its political funding, where outdated equipment can fail and cause a nationwide collapse. In contrast, Canada's air navigation service provider, NAV Canada, operates as a non-profit organization outside of government. It collects its funding from airline ticket sales, which Gradek said shields it from political funding decisions. "We're the envy of the world in Canada in terms of how we have our air-traffic control systems in place, and the management of those systems by NAV Canada," Gradek said. He added that he had never seen such fragility where one wire could bring down an entire system.
The FAA said the outage was caused by excess data flooding the air-traffic control system, causing intermittent disruptions to communications and radar feeds. On Sunday, the agency described a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, as potential sources. U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said a contractor had replaced old copper wire with new fibre wire at the Arkansas site, and when the router was turned on, a problem cropped up in Texas, cascading into the ground stop. Duffy pressed Congress for billions of dollars in upgrades to the air-traffic control infrastructure during multiple Sunday news show appearances. "I can’t apologize for what was passed on to us. And I can’t blame Republicans or Democrats, because it’s all of them. It goes back, 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment," he told NBC's "Meet the Press." He later called for $50 billion in upgrades and warned that it would take time to restore full capacity ahead of the busy Thanksgiving travel period.
In an emailed statement, NAV Canada said its systems were not affected by Friday's outage in the United States, and air-traffic services in Canadian airspace continue to operate normally. The statement pointed to $3.5 billion the organization has invested in the air-traffic management system and associated infrastructure. "Redundancy is built in at multiple levels, including backup systems and established contingency procedures that our teams train on regularly so that operations can continue safely," spokesperson Maryam Amini said. The outage stranded thousands of travellers across the U.S. More than 4,700 flights were cancelled and 10,000 were delayed on Friday, with another 700 cancelled for Saturday, according to FlightRadar24. Novello Desserts reported on November 13 that the FAA halt caused delays for flights to and from Canada. U.S. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said there was no suspected cyberattack and the public was never in danger.
With files from The Canadian Press, Narcity and CityNews